Vintage Dog Cookie Jars – Finding the Real McCoy


Mugsy the Dog cookie jar by Shawnee.

Mugsy the Dog cookie jar by Shawnee.

THERE ARE A NUMBER of reasons cookie jars make such popular large collectibles. Not only do they brighten up a kitchen or display, but they are functional and affordable.

The cookie jar is a successor to the British Biscuit tin. They come in the most enormous range of size, colour, design and materials. Naturally this means there is a lovely array of figural and decorative dog cookie jars.

Dog cookie jars can be collected by breed, maker, time period or a combination of these three. It is wise to conduct appropriate research before diving into this collectible market as there is a high occurrence of knock-off and reproduction cookie jars in the marketplace.

The Real McCoy? Vintage McCoy Dog Cookie Jar.

The Real McCoy? Vintage McCoy Dog Cookie Jar.

Cookie jars made to look like people, animals or other objects were not really produced until the 1940s so finding a dog cookie jar older than this is unlikely. The jars produced between 1940 and 1970 are the most rare and therefore vulnerable to being copied.

One of the most famous cookie jar collectors was Andy Warhol. The sale of 136 jars from Warhol’s collection, mostly gleaned from flea markets and junk shops of Manhattan, fetched $198,605 at a Sotheby’s auction in 1988. This event means Warhol probably did more for elevating the status of cookie jar collecting than any other single person in their history.

Brayton Laguna Plaid Dog Cookie Jar

Vintage 1943 California Brayton Laguna Plaid Dog Cookie Jar.

As with all purchases in the antiques and collectibles market education is the key. If you are interested in collecting dog cookie jars, your first purchases should be a couple of cookie jar resource books.

The large size which makes a colorful or detailed cookie jar such a thing of beauty is also its downfall as a collectible. As your dog cookie jar collection grows, displaying them can become an issue. With this in mind, why not save your money and buy just a few really good pieces. Would you rather have five $20 jars or one really superb $100 dog cookie jar? 

A few things to consider before buying a collectible dog cookie jar are:

1. Manufacturing flaws. These come about when the jar is made and are usually small air pockets in the material or thin spots/runs in the paint.

2. Lids, rims and bases are susceptible to chips and require careful inspection. Remove the lid and inspect the inside of the jar as well as the outside. Running your finger around edges and lips will often reveal a crack or chip missed during a visual inspection.

3. Hairline Cracks. These are small cracks that didn’t quite break the jar but have more than likely weakened it and made the jar fragile. An easy way to spot them is to let a light reflect on the jar while turning it. Any hairline cracks will stand out under the reflection.

St Bernard with Keg, Dog Cookie Jar.

St Bernard with Keg, Dog Cookie Jar.

4. Crazing or Crack? If you are not certain whether your jar has a hairline crack or just a little crazing, try the sound test. Flick the jar with your finger and listen to the sound it makes. Is it a flat sound or does it ring like a bell? A crack in a jar makes a flat sound whereas a little crazing on the jar and it will still ring like a bell.

5. Cold Paint or Glaze. This refers to the coloring and decoration of the jar. Cold paint is applied after the jar is fired and can sometimes peel. This is opposed to paint being applied “under the glaze” which is hardier. Most glazes are glossy and look like a clear coating over the paint.

6. Buying online. As always, when buying online at auctions or websites look for the feedback and testimonials the seller has received. You can quite quickly pick a pattern as to whether the items they sell are as described (or better!); whether the cookie jar is genuine. Also, ask about any guarantees with regard to condition and authenticity and don’t be shy about asking for a re-inspection of the item prior to bidding (if at auction) or buying if the jar is offered at a fixed price.

Buy dog cooke jars here.

You can browse an extensive range of dog cookie jars for sale here.

Related posts:

  1. Dishy Vintage Dog Towels
Posted by Edman on Oct 11 2010. Filed under Featured Dogs, Kitchenalia, Vintage Dogs. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

6 Comments for “Vintage Dog Cookie Jars – Finding the Real McCoy”

  1. I really love your vintage cookie jars but, do u have a yellow lab. jar? That’s what I really want!! Hope to hear from u soon. Thanks, Sheila Levy

  2. I really love your vintage dog cookie jars. Do u have one in the yellow lab? That’s what I need. Hope to hear from u soon. Thanks, Sheila Levy

  3. I have a mugsy dog cookie jar without the flowers and small salt and pepper dog set. The cookie jar has USA on the bottom, is it a Shawnee or a no name brand? Also would you know the value of my set? Thank You Donna

  4. I have a McCoy thinking dog cookie biscuit jar wanting indormation about? Thanks Lora

  5. looking for droopy dog cartoon cookie jar?

  6. Looking for any kind of droopy dog cookie jar – cartoon character

Leave a Reply

Recently Commented

  • Christopher Mollard: Hi, Are you interested in selling it? I’d love to see pictures if so! I’m a huge fan
  • Christopher Mollard: Hi do you still have them available? I have been looking everywhere for an original!
  • Jansson: Hey! I wonder if anyone knows anything about this Bonzo paperweight that is made of wood and stands on a...
  • Karen: I have a very old Lucy Dawson In a very old style frame I got it from my dads room when he passed away and I...
  • will: Hi I have a nipper made from solid cast iron. its approximately 13 1/2 inch tall. and has been painted 2/3...